|
|
Newsletter — Issue 59 — Tuesday, November 17, 2026
|
|
This newsletter has been published by Engage Colorado.
|
|
Amendment 87 Passed. Now What?
Dancing on the Grave of Colorado’s Vibrant Future
This Engage Colorado Newsletter reflects the personal opinions of Dan Caruso, written with the support of the Caruso Ventures team.
|
|
|
|
Amendment 87 was the central issue of the fall. Sixteen Engage Colorado issues in a row were centered on it. The series opened in August with “Dumb and Dumber”: the Colorado AI Act was Dumb, and a graduated income tax would be Dumber.
Dumber prevailed.
Amendment 87 passed with about 51.5% of the vote, roughly 80,000 votes out of more than 2.6 million cast.
On Thursday, November 5, supporters gathered at La Raza Park in northwest Denver. State Rep. Lorena Garcia led the crowd in a chant: “Tax the rich!”
“What is today?” she asked. “It’s tax the rich day.”
I see it differently. When I watch the supporters celebrating, I see dancing on the grave of Colorado’s vibrant future.
On Wednesday, The Denver Gazette reported on the reaction under the headline “Business worries grow in Colorado after graduated tax system passes.” Here is what I told them:
|
|
“I imagine the smiles on the faces of the economic development teams in Texas, Arizona, Utah, Nevada, Tennessee and Wyoming. Jobs that belong in Colorado are going to go there.”
“Jobs and job creators will avoid Colorado and depart from it. The opportunity for our children and grandchildren to build careers here has been forfeited. Smaller businesses and the hospitality sector will watch their customers spend that money in another state. Nonprofits will watch their donors redirect their giving to their new communities.”
“And the revenue increase will be temporary. When California raised its top rates, 45% of the expected new revenue from top earners vanished within a year, 61% within two. Spending won’t fall with it. That is when the politicians come back to every Coloradan demanding higher taxes.”
|
|
Where Do We Go From Here?
Let’s be pragmatic. Most of Colorado’s political leaders see the passage of Amendment 87 as good for Colorado. They see more tax dollars to fund more spending, and they generally believe the increased spending will benefit Coloradans. Colorado has moved even more decisively to the far left. And the far left is convinced that a graduated income tax is a victory worth chanting about.
In this environment, I see two choices for myself.
|
Choice one: Retreat
On a personal level, Amendment 87 is frustrating but not life changing. I want more for Colorado than to watch it slide toward economic mediocrity. At the same time, political activism has never been a priority for me. Frankly, I haven’t enjoyed spending so much time on it over the last several months. The passage of 87 is a legitimate reason for me to spend my time on my real passions.
To borrow from Bruce Springsteen’s “No Surrender,” I can recognize there’s a war outside still raging but it’s not mine anymore to win.
|
Choice two: No Surrender
Amendment 87 passed by a narrow margin during a historic blue wave. Nearly as many Coloradans voted against a graduated income tax as voted for it.
When the Colorado AI Act passed, we fought it. It was rewritten.
Springsteen’s song is about blood brothers on a stormy night with a vow to defend; retreat and surrender is not an option. But he implies this is naive, like the romantic dreams in his head.
|
No Rush
I don’t know what my answer is right now. On one hand, why should I spend my limited time on an insurmountable challenge that isn’t my war to win? On the other hand, am I ready to give up on what should be a realistic goal: Colorado as the most attractive innovation ecosystem in the world, with every Coloradan sharing in the economic and cultural prosperity that comes from being the world’s leading geography for innovation?
I’ll let some time pass before reaching any conclusions. In the meantime, I will focus on The Chill House at Pearl West, the arrival of the Sundance Film Festival, and the 2027 Tulagi Fest.
|
|
|
|
|